While neither gaozi nor mencius is willing to entertain the notion that human beings might originally be evil, this is the cornerstone of xunzi's position on human nature against mencius, xunzi defines human nature as what is inborn and unlearned, and then asks why education and ritual are necessary for mencius if people really are good by nature. Like shang yang, xunzi believed that humanity's inborn tendencies were evil and that ethical norms had been invented to rectify people xunzi's variety of confucianism therefore has a darker, more pragmatic flavour than the optimistic confucianism of mencius , who tended to view humans as innately good , though like most confucians he . Mencius's emphasis on the innate human moral nature was a rebuttal against the writings of mo tzu and early taoists who did not think human intentions/motives mattered it was also a rebuttal to the taoists/daoists, who did not think worldly matters were worthy of human consideration. Compare mencius and hsun tzu human nature wendy swartz the nature of evil hsun tzu's philosophy is built from the idea that human beings are by nature inherently evil, and the good they produce will only come through their conscious activity. The view of evil human nature is important in chinese and western cultures the thesis chooses evil human in st augustine’s thoughts and hsun tzu’s thoughts to compare and analyze evil in these two st augustine, who is called “the saint of god”, views the definition of evil, the resource .
Is human nature originally good or evil mencius hsun tzu views wendy swartz the nature of evil hsun tzu's philosophy is built from the idea that human beings are by nature inherently evil , and the good they produce will only come through their conscious activity. Is human nature intrinsically good or evil why i believe that everyone is essentially good unlike what hsun tzu says: he is born with feelings of envy and hate . Mencius versus hsun tzu how might mencius perceive the nature of evil if human beings are naturally good, where might evil originate a man needs .
Check out our top free essays on is human nature originally good or evil mencius hsun tzu views to help you write your own essay. Philosophy ch 1 confucianism mencius- human nature is originally good realistic wing hsun-tzu- human nature is originally evil heart (mencius). Xunzi’s view of human nature that man’s nature should be good, essay “ man’s nature is evil” because mencius believed that human beings were . In the several extracts from the book of mencius, mencius to oppose the claim that human nature is neither good nor bad, but instead good while from the book of hsun-tzu, hsun-tzu states the opposite, that humans are naturally evil.
Mencius believes that humans are born with good nature while hsun tzu believed that all humans are born evil, but they can be taught to become good plato believes that human beings had a desire to seek one another in an attempt to complete them. Is human nature originally good, as confucius and mencius claimed, or is it originally evil, as hsiin tzu claimed these philosophers sought to provide a theoretical foundation for their advocacy of confucian ethics, social and political philosophy and, on a more practical level, the confucian way of life. Hsun tzu believed that human nature was the same in everyone no one starts off with moral principles an increase in greed and struggle for power amidst numerous regimes in china lead hsun tzu to his belief that people were not inherently good due to the outbreak of corrupt governance and economic status. Hsun tzu, one of confucian scholars, puts forward evil human nature which is totally different from good human nature in confucianism he views the definition of evil, the source of it, and ways to change evil into good from the angle of social reality in warring states period. All the arguments that hsun tzu makes here have supported my views about man’s nature being evil on man’s nature is evil – hsun tzuu of good/evil .
Hsun-tzu could not accept mencius idealistic view of human nature, nor did he believe that heaven was the sole arbiter of human behavior good versus evil . Summary of confucianism on human nature is human nature originally good or evil mencius subscribed to the former, while hsun-tzu to the latter mencius tries to . Both mencius and hsun tzu seem to have fairly reasonable arguments for their points of view on human nature mencius believes that humans, by nature, are in all ways good, while tzu believes that humans are actually the opposite of that, evil. Mencius’ view on human nature mencius is best known for his view that human nature is intrinsically benevolent its ingredients are ‘benevolent knowledge’ and ‘benevolent ability’ in mencius’ terms.
This can be backed up when mencius talks to kao tzu about human nature kao tzu thought that humans were like “whirling water,” that they do not show any preference for good nor for bad, just as whirling water does not. Mencius, (latin), chinese (pinyin) mengzi or (wade-giles) meng-tzu evil is not part of human nature but is the result of poor upbringing or lack of education . Mencius goodness of human nature xunzi challenged mencius' positive concept of human nature as fundamentally good mencius vs xunzi education. Start studying mencius vs hsun tzu learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools humans are good by nature human nature is .